Bitpunk

Stock Basics · How the stock market works · Lesson 3 / 27

Pension Savings vs. IRP: How Do the Tax Benefits and Withdrawal Rules Differ

5 min read · · Korean original

Contents 4
  1. Tax Credit Limits: Pension Savings vs. IRP
  2. Taxes on Early Withdrawals from Pension Savings
  3. IRP: Early Withdrawal vs. Closing the Account
  4. How Much Should You Put into Pension Savings and an IRP?

When you hear that you can cut your taxes at year-end tax settlement, putting money into a pension account starts to sound tempting. But before you deposit anything, you may also wonder, "If I move or need a lump sum later, can I take the money back out?"

The easiest way to compare a pension savings account and an Individual Retirement Pension (IRP) is to look at how much tax each saves you, and how freely you can withdraw money when you need it in a hurry. Pension savings qualify for the tax credit on up to KRW 6 million a year, and adding an IRP raises that to KRW 9 million a year. In exchange, the IRP has stricter conditions for taking out only the money you need partway through.

Tax Credit Limits: Pension Savings vs. IRP

A tax credit is a benefit that subtracts a certain amount from the income tax you owe. Money you put into pension savings counts toward the tax credit up to KRW 6 million a year, and when you combine all pension accounts, including an IRP, up to KRW 9 million a year counts. Note that KRW 6 million and KRW 9 million are not amounts you get back. They are the contribution amounts used to calculate your tax benefit.Source 1National Tax Service, Guide to Pension Account Tax Credits for Earned Income

Let's say you put KRW 9 million toward your retirement this year. If you put KRW 6 million into pension savings and KRW 3 million into an IRP, the full KRW 9 million counts toward the tax credit. If you put all KRW 9 million into pension savings alone, only KRW 6 million of it counts.

So how much does your tax actually go down? For salaried workers, the rate is 15% if total salary is KRW 55 million or less, and 12% if it is higher. When the test is based on gross comprehensive income instead, the threshold is KRW 45 million, and these rates do not include local income tax.

If you contributed KRW 6 million to pension savings, the calculated credit is KRW 900,000 at 15% and KRW 720,000 at 12%. This amount is separate from any returns you earn by investing inside the account. Looking at the tax benefit and the investment returns separately makes the math much less confusing.

Taxes on Early Withdrawals from Pension Savings

You can withdraw money from pension savings partway through. However, if you take out principal that received a tax credit, or investment returns, without receiving them as a pension, a 16.5% other income tax generally applies. Withdrawals made for unavoidable reasons defined in tax law follow separate rules.Source 2KDI Economic Information and Education Center, Consumer Advisory for a Stable Retirement

Suppose you make a regular early withdrawal of KRW 1 million from principal that received a tax credit. The tax on that would be KRW 165,000. You might think, "Why am I paying tax to take out my own money?" The reason is that this money already received a tax benefit when you put it in.

That doesn't mean the entire withdrawal is automatically multiplied by 16.5%. Taxation differs depending on whether the money is principal that received a tax credit, principal that didn't, or returns from investing. That's why the account balance alone can't tell you how much tax you'll pay on a withdrawal.

Even when they share the "pension savings" name, the products differ. Pension savings insurance may come with a surrender charge in addition to taxes when you cancel it. With a pension savings fund, you choose the funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) yourself, so you can lose principal depending on how your investments perform.

IRP: Early Withdrawal vs. Closing the Account

With an IRP, having money in the account doesn't mean you can take out as much as you need right away. An early withdrawal, where you take out part of the balance, requires a reason set out in law. Examples include a person who owns no home buying a house in their own name, or paying a lease deposit (jeonse) or security deposit for housing. Medical expenses for illness or injury also qualify, but only if set requirements such as duration and amount are met.

Here, an early withdrawal and closing the account are different things. An early withdrawal means taking out part of the money while keeping the account open, while closing means ending the account entirely. If you don't have a qualifying reason for an early withdrawal, you can't take out just the money you need, and you may end up considering closing the account.

Generally, when you close an IRP, a 16.5% other income tax applies to principal contributions that received a tax credit and to investment returns. Don't take this to mean the same rate applies to any severance pay held in the account. What it covers here is principal contributions that received a tax credit and investment returns.

Even when an early withdrawal is allowed, the tax doesn't go away. Buying a home as a person who owns no home is a valid reason to withdraw, but other income tax still applies to principal that received a tax credit and to investment returns. "Can I take it out?" and "Can I take it out tax-free?" are two different questions.

How Much Should You Put into Pension Savings and an IRP?

If the amount you want counted toward the tax credit is within KRW 6 million a year, you don't need to add an IRP to raise your credit limit. Pension savings alone can cover that amount. If you've filled KRW 6 million in pension savings and still have room to save more for retirement, you can add IRP contributions and count up to KRW 9 million a year toward the credit.Source 1National Tax Service, Guide to Pension Account Tax Credits for Earned Income

There's no need to put next year's moving deposit or the living expenses you'll need soon into the account just to hit the credit limit. If you withdraw money or close the account partway through and end up with taxes and fees, the benefit you were counting on shrinks. Set aside the money you'll need in the near future, and base your contributions on what you can leave untouched until retirement.

When choosing between pension savings and an IRP, look at the tax credit limits and the early withdrawal conditions together. The rule of thumb isn't to max out the limit, but to put in only as much as you won't need to take out along the way.

AUTHORAbout the author

BitpunkCrypto research editor

Writing about the crypto market since 2018. 448 articles so far, from blockchain basics to trading, interest rates and macro, plus 16 investing tools built and run in-house. Now building step-by-step learning tracks for investing, stocks and crypto.

※ For information only. Not investment advice.

Most read in Tools & Resources

See all
Tools & ResourcesWonyotti Update and Complete Summary of His Trading Method AMA (KRW 6 Million → KRW 300 Billion)34 min · Tools & ResourcesWhere to Check the Bitcoin Greed Index | The Bitcoin Fear & Greed Index Explained3 min · Tools & ResourcesSmart Pension Investing: How to Save on Taxes with an ISA Account and Transfer It to a Pension Account7 min ·